Tiger Lily 2$$
The clear No. 1 on both platforms: the highest Yelp rating in Fishers (4.6 on 227) paired with a 4.7 Google rating, for a family-run Hong Kong/Korean-rooted spot reviewers call the best Chinese in Indianapolis.
All cities › Indiana › Fishers
Ranked from a comprehensive review of Google and Yelp — rating and review count on both platforms, quality weighed against volume. Fishers population 104,812; figures researched November 2026. How we rank →
The clear No. 1 on both platforms: the highest Yelp rating in Fishers (4.6 on 227) paired with a 4.7 Google rating, for a family-run Hong Kong/Korean-rooted spot reviewers call the best Chinese in Indianapolis.
The strongest quality pairing outside Fishers itself: 4.5 on Google (168 reviews, via Sluurpy's Google tally) and 4.3 on Yelp (148), with reviewers singling out its Chinese menu over nearby rivals.
The area's most-reviewed authentic Chinese kitchen: 372 Yelp reviews plus a 4.3 Google rating, with a separate traditional/Sichuan menu and soup dumplings praised by diners who have eaten in China.
Ranked on sheer volume: 884 Google reviews at 4.2 and 467 Yelp reviews dwarf every other entry, even though Yelp's 3.0 shows the chain experience is polarizing. This is the Keystone Crossing flagship only; no other location is summed in.
A hidden-gem takeout with the second-highest Google rating on the list (4.4 on 233) and dishes like beef chow fun that reviewers say are hard to find outside big-city Chinatowns; a weaker Yelp score keeps it below the top four.
The best-balanced northeast Indianapolis takeout: 4.3 Google and 4.1 Yelp on triple-digit reviews on both platforms, with longtime regulars calling it authentic and a favorite since 2018.
Carmel's workhorse Chinese restaurant: solid 4.1/3.8 ratings on 182 Google and 109 Yelp reviews, plus heavy delivery praise for freshness and value on the Fishers border.
Fishers' best-reviewed pure takeout inside city limits after Tiger Lily 2: 4.2 on Google and 3.9 on Yelp, both on well over 100 reviews, for friendly, reasonably priced carryout.
A high Google rating (4.3 on 233) backed by a respectable Yelp showing east of Fishers, known for generous portions and crab rangoon that regulars defend fiercely.
The most consistent mid-tier entry: an identical 3.9 on both platforms, with reviewers praising fresh, not-too-salty cooking and the egg drop wonton soup as the best they have had.
A clean, busy 96th Street takeout/dine-in hybrid: 4.1 Google on 166 reviews and Yelp's top-listed Fishers Chinese entry at 3.9, praised for service and freshness.
East Fishers' delivery staple with the largest Google review count of any Fishers-proper takeout (191 at 3.9) and a loyal Yelp following calling it their go-to for delivered Chinese.
A distinct Allisonville Road location (not summed with the Fishers China Wok): 4.1 Google and 3.8 Yelp, with reviewers calling its lo mein the most flavorful of any local takeout. Ranked as this named location only.
A smaller-volume Allisonville staple: a good 4.1 Google rating keeps it in the 20 despite a thinner Yelp base (3.4 on 47) than the entries above it.
Included on volume, not love: 776 Google reviews (3.4, via RestaurantJump/Birdeye tallies) make it one of the most-reviewed Chinese restaurants in the area, but Yelp's 2.5 warns the cheap buffet is hit-or-miss.
Next door to Tiger Lily 2 but a different proposition: the Fishers Crossing buffet draws big review volume on both platforms (231 Google, 176 Yelp) at low-3 ratings, so it ranks on reach rather than acclaim.
A perfectly even evidence profile — 3.7 on both Google (150) and Yelp (62) — for a family-owned Carmel takeout some Yelp reviewers call the best Chinese in Carmel.
The Geist-area Happy Dragon (a separate location from the Fishers one, ranked on its own figures only): 3.8 Google and 3.6 Yelp, with 15-year regulars in its Yelp reviews.
Another dead-even profile — 3.5 on both platforms — for a decade-old Fishers takeout on 126th Street with fast, efficient service praised in reviews.
The final Fishers-proper spot: a middling 3.5 Google rating on 125 reviews carries it in, but Yelp's 2.8 on 66 is the weakest Yelp score in the 20 — it edges out Carmel's China Garden on the Fishers-first scope rule.
Scope: Fishers proper favored (7 of 20), with Carmel (5), Indianapolis (7, mostly the northeast Castleton/Allisonville/Shadeland corridor, plus Tian Fu on W 86th St and P.F. Chang's at Keystone Crossing) and Noblesville (1) completing the Fishers dining area. West-side Indianapolis (Imperial Palace, Asian Snack, Lucky Lou/Taste) and south-side spots were excluded as outside the Fishers dining area despite strong Yelp scores. Google figures were read from Google-mirroring aggregators (Restaurantji for most entries; Sluurpy's explicit Google tally for Asian Kitchen, 4.5/168; RestaurantJump/Birdeye tallies for Number One China Buffet, 3.4/776) because Google Maps pages do not render in text fetch; aggregator counts vary slightly by crawl date (e.g. Tiger Lily 2 also seen at 4.7/311 and Hong Kong Carmel at 4.4/230), so the Restaurantji figure was used consistently where available. Yelp figures are all from live Yelp search/listing pages crawled 2026-11-16/17. No figure was invented; every entry has both platforms. Judgment calls: Bento Cafe (Yelp Chinese list, 4.1/419) was excluded as primarily sushi/Japanese, as were Yummy Bowl (Mongolian grill) and The Monk's (primarily Indian) — not counted as Chinese. China Garden in Carmel (Google 3.6/119, Yelp 3.1/61) and Happy Cuisine in McCordsville (Google 3.9/125, no Yelp figure obtained) just missed the cut. Two distinct China Wok and two distinct Happy Dragon locations are ranked separately on their own figures, never summed, per the multi-location rule. Chef Tang (opened Nov 3, 2026 in the former Benyue space) has no meaningful review base yet. Fishers is a thin, mostly Chinese-American takeout market: there is no dedicated dim sum house, hot pot, or hand-pulled noodle shop in the 20, and ratings below the top 6 fall quickly into the mid-3s — the list is a full 20, but the drop-off after the top tier is real and reflected in the ranking.